Russula benwooii — Ben Woo's russula

Ben Woo's russula

Ben Woo's russula1, photograph by Benjamin Woo with permission from University of Washington, Burke Museum.

Ben Woo's russula

Ben Woo's russula6, photograph by Benjamin Woo with permission from University of Washington, Burke Museum.

Ben Woo's russula

Ben Woo's russula7, red-brown variant, photograph by Benjamin Woo with permission from University of Washington, Burke Museum.

Ben Woo's russula

Ben Woo's russula8, purple variant, photograph by Benjamin Woo with permission from University of Washington, Burke Museum.

Ben Woo's russula spores

Ben Woo's russula9, sketch of basidiospores by Benjamin Woo with permission from University of Washington, Burke Museum.


A firm, and stout mushroom with a matt cap surface.

Odour: Mild.
Taste: Usually mild, occasionally (~1 out of 5) somewhat spicy/acrid (taste and then spit out a pea-sized piece of the gills after holding it in your mouth for a moment).
Cap: 6.5–15 cm in diameter, starting out convex, and flattening out, but keeping a central depression, sometimes cracking from the margin inwards. Colours vary greatly, from black purple, via red-brown or orange-brown to yellow, tan, or even completely yellow-green. The surface may have irregular bumps that are noticeable to touch. When wet, the surface is somewhat viscid. Cap margins are slightly grooved (striate).
Gills: Close together, cream-coloured. Only with a few short gills between the long gills.
Stems: 6–14 cm long x 1 –2 cm wide, as long as the cap's width or longer, often somewhat club-shaped, widest at the base, and sold. The colour is white, often with a pink or vinaceous blush. The stem may turn brown when scratched.
Ring or veil: None.
Cup: None.
Spores: 9-9.5 x 6.5-7 µm, with isolated robust spines (see sketch above).
Habitat: On soil, in mature western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla) or mixed coniferous forests. Ectomycorrhizal.
Geographical distribution: Throughout the Pacific northwest (Oregon, Washington) and BC.

Russulas are easy to recognize to genus by their brittle flesh and white- to cream-coloured gills. Unlike the related genus Lactarius, they do not ooze milky or coloured juice (latex) where cut or broken. However, russulas are notoriously difficult to identify to species. Many species are variable in cap colour. And this species is a beautiful example of that, as the cap can have all kinds of colours. Collection records4 show that Ben Woo's russula is common enough in Pacific northwest and BC so that large, brownish, mild-tasting russulas with cream-coloured gills will often turn out to be members of this species. However, the identification will be difficult to verify without DNA sequencing.
Russula benwooii is often mistaken for a species in the complex of the shrimp russula, Russula xerampelina, but it is less likely to stain brown on the stem and it lacks the fishy or shrimp-like smell.

Mild-tasting russulas are often eaten. However, russulas that cause gastrointestinal upsets are rarely identified to species5. Although the Ben Woo's russula has yet to be directly implicated in a poisoning, there is no direct evidence that it is safe to eat. Ben Woo's russula is difficult to distinguish from other species. Best to give this one a pass.

Treatment: Contact your regional Poison Control Centre if you or someone you know is ill after eating wild mushrooms. Poison Centres provide free, expert medical advice 24 hours a day, seven days a week. If possible, save the mushrooms or some of the leftover food containing the mushrooms to help confirm identification.

Poison Control:
British Columbia: 604-682-5050 or 1-800-567-8911.
United States (WA, OR, ID): 1-800-222-1222.

1
Specimen Russula benwooii WTU-F-038603, GenBank #KX813142.

2
Hyde, K. D. et al. Fungal diversity notes 603-708: taxonomic and phylogenetic notes on genera and species. Fungal Diversity 87, 1-135 (2017).

3
Bazzicalupo, A. L. et al. Troubles with mycorrhizal mushroom identification where morphological differentiation lags behind barcode sequence divergence. Taxon 66, 791-810, doi:10.12705/664.1 (2017).

4
Bazzicalupo, A. & Carmean, D. Ben Woo's Russula Mushrooms, <http://advance.science.sfu.ca/fungi/index.php?-link=Home> accessed March 2018.

5
Beug, M. W., Shaw, M. & Cochran, K. W. Thirty-plus years of mushroom poisoning: Summary of the approximately 2,000 reports in the NAMA case registry. McIlvainea 16, 47-68 (2006).

6
Specimen Russula benwooii WTU-F-038385, GenBank #KX813334.

7
Specimen Russula benwooii WTU-F_038723, GenBank #KX813471.

8
Specimen Russula benwooii WTU-F_038605, GenBank #KX813144.

9
Specimen Russula benwooii WTU-F_038400, GenBank #KX813074.